Bathtub Replacement vs. Full Remodel: Which Fits Your Budget in Melbourne?
In Melbourne, even a simple bathroom decision can quickly spiral into a costly dilemma. Should you replace your bathtub or commit to a full remodel?
Every year, thousands of Melbourne homeowners face the same choice, refresh what’s broken or start from scratch. The decision impacts not only your budget but your comfort, your home’s value, and your daily life during renovation. Here’s a clear, fact-based guide built from local research, real contractor data, and homeowner experiences to help you decide what truly fits your budget and lifestyle.
Fast Facts
- Average Cost: Bathtub replacements in Melbourne range from A$1,200–A$5,000, while full remodels reach A$60,000+
- Hidden Costs: Structural or waterproofing issues can add A$3,000–A$8,000 unexpectedly
- Timeline: Replacements take about 3–7 days; remodels may run 3–8 weeks
- ROI: Full remodels can boost home value by up to 10%; replacements by 1–3%
- Tip: Add a 10–20% contingency for surprises like water damage or code upgrades
The Real Cost Divide in Melbourne
Bathtub replacements in Melbourne typically cost between A$1,200 and A$5,000, depending on the tub type and installation complexity. Basic acrylic tubs can start at A$500, while freestanding luxury models push beyond A$10,000 when demolition or waterproofing is required. One Melbourne Redditor shared their replacement came in just under A$15,000 but only after factoring in surprise repairs.
Full bathroom remodels, on the other hand, range from A$10,000 to A$60,000+. Small remodels sit around A$15,000, while high-end designs with new layouts and luxury finishes can exceed A$45,000. Mid-range projects hover near A$25,000 to A$35,000. Melbourne’s labour and permit costs often push totals 10–20% higher than the national average.
Hidden costs are where most budgets crack. Structural issues after demolition can add A$3,000–A$8,000. Plumbing reroutes, electrical upgrades, and waterproofing typically add several thousand more. Contractors advise a 10–20% contingency buffer for surprises like mould, water damage, or outdated pipes. Without this buffer, more than 40% of renovations go over budget.
Disruption vs. Convenience During Renovation
Many Melbourne homeowners underestimate how disruptive bathroom work can be. For a simple bathtub replacement, expect 3–7 days of activity with plumbers and tilers coming and going. Dust and noise are limited, and most homes can stay fully occupied.
A full remodel, however, brings 5–10 trades on-site for 3–8 weeks. Walls may be stripped back, tiles removed, and floors relevelled. Noise, dust, and reduced access to the home’s only bathroom become real pain points. Contractors managing occupied homes, such as Skilled Tradies Melbourne, phase their work to maintain livability. They set up dust barriers, schedule essential tasks early, and often provide temporary facilities for convenience. Still, this service typically adds 10–20% to costs.
Common homeowner complaints include delayed timelines, lingering mess, and unexpected noise during early hours. Communication with the contractor is key, daily progress updates and clear project schedules reduce frustration.
Related Insight
Before you begin any bathroom upgrade, make sure you understand local compliance rules. Learn more in Victoria’s bathroom renovation laws.
Function vs. Fashion: What Actually Adds Value
In Melbourne, functionality outperforms trends every time. Around 70–80% of homeowners now prioritise durable, low-maintenance design over fleeting styles. Common reasons for upgrading include poor layout, leaking plumbing, bad ventilation, or ageing waterproofing.
For small fixes, a bathtub replacement may solve leaks or cosmetic flaws. But when problems extend to layout or plumbing, about 70% of cases, only a full remodel delivers lasting results. Features like proper ventilation, LED lighting, and durable waterproofing provide usability for over 20 years, compared to 10–15 years for a simple tub upgrade.
| Feature Type | Bathtub Replacement | Full Remodel |
|---|---|---|
| Usability (ventilation, fixtures) | Basic upgrades; 10–15 year life | Comprehensive; 20+ year life |
| Cosmetic (tiles, paint) | Minimal; quick refresh | Extensive; fully customisable |
Does It Pay Off? Value and Resale in Melbourne
A bathtub replacement offers a modest 1–3% uplift in home value (around A$5,000–A$10,000). It’s ideal when selling soon or upgrading a rental. A full remodel adds 4–10% uplift (A$20,000–A$50,000+), especially in middle and upper suburbs where buyers expect modern bathrooms. Real estate agents confirm that fresh bathrooms can help homes sell up to 10% faster.
Still, over-capitalising is a common risk. Installing luxury finishes in an average suburb can erase ROI. Experts recommend keeping bathroom investment near 2% of total property value. Under-spending is equally risky: cutting corners often leads to water leaks and quick wear, reducing long-term appeal.
If you plan to stay for years, a full remodel offers comfort and durability. If selling soon, a well-done tub replacement delivers better cost efficiency.
Quick Insight
Curious what Melbourne homeowners ask most before renovating? Discover answers to the top local queries in Melbourne’s most Googled bathroom renovation questions.
Risks, Hidden Problems, and Trade Quality
Melbourne’s building regulations are strict for a reason. Unlicensed or underqualified trades can turn small jobs into disasters. Always verify registration with the Victorian Building Authority (VBA). Builders working on projects over A$10,000 must be VBA-registered. Plumbers, electricians, and waterproofers need valid trade licenses and public liability insurance. Experienced trades (15+ years) are worth the cost.
Frequent renovation mistakes include focusing on style instead of structure, skipping waterproofing certifications, or hiring unlicensed contractors. Bathtub replacements often conceal deeper issues like cracked joists or failed membranes. Full remodels, while more expensive, expose and fix these problems early.
Professional builders prevent hidden surprises through pre-inspections, detailed written quotes, and thorough documentation of site conditions. Reliable contractors add 10–20% contingencies to their pricing to avoid mid-project shocks.
Seasonal factors also matter. Between September and February, Melbourne’s peak renovation season drives up prices 15–20%. Labour shortages and material delays can further extend timelines. Planning early and sourcing materials locally help minimise these issues.
Which Choice Fits Your Budget?
Your decision comes down to five key factors: budget, bathroom condition, lifestyle, timeline, and property goals.
- Budget: If your limit is under A$5,000, stick to a bathtub replacement.
- Condition: If leaks, mould, or poor layout exist, choose a full remodel.
- Lifestyle: For minimal disruption, go with a quick replacement.
- Timeline: Need it done fast? Replacement takes a week; remodel takes up to two months.
- Goals: Staying long-term? Remodel. Selling soon? Replace selectively.
Some homeowners find a middle ground by updating tiles, fixtures, and paint for A$5,000–A$10,000. This “mini remodel” delivers about 60–70% of the visual upgrade of a full remodel at half the cost, though it doesn’t fix deep structural flaws.
The Melbourne Reality Check
Local conditions heavily influence costs. Labour in Melbourne averages A$100–A$150 per hour. Older homes often require plumbing reroutes or heritage permit applications, adding 20–30% to costs. Building codes demand waterproofing per AS 3740/NCC, including full floor coverage and wall sealing to 150–1800mm height. Permits for plumbing or structure changes cost A$500–A$1,000 and take up to four weeks to process.
Material prices also fluctuate. Tiles rose 10–15% in 2025, and premium tubs can exceed A$2,000. Trade shortages continue, so homeowners should lock in quotes early to avoid inflation.
Case studies highlight the consequences of poor planning. A Melbourne homeowner reported spending A$30,000 extra after uncovering waterproofing defects mid-project. VBA and VCAT complaints reveal similar stories of hidden mould, unlicensed work, and underpriced quotes that turned into long-term losses.
Think Beyond Tiles
A Melbourne bathroom renovation is never just about looks. It’s about solving structural issues, improving comfort, and safeguarding your home’s value. For some, a simple bathtub swap brings a quick refresh. For others, only a full remodel restores function and peace of mind.
Before choosing, weigh your goals, timeline, and the true condition of your space. The cheapest option may fix what you see, but the smartest investment fixes what you can’t.
Also Read
Thinking of upgrading your bathroom during the colder months? Find out how to plan smartly with our guide to winter bathroom renovations in Melbourne.
FAQ
How much does a bathroom remodel cost in Melbourne?
Between A$10,000 and A$60,000+, depending on size, materials, and layout.
Is replacing a bathtub cheaper than remodeling the whole bathroom?
Yes, typically A$1,200–A$5,000 versus A$20,000–A$40,000+.
Can I live in my house during renovation?
Yes, but expect disruption. Occupied sites add 10–20% to cost due to containment and cleaning.
What adds more value to my home?
A full remodel increases value by up to 10%; a replacement by 1–3%.
How long does a remodel take?
Replacements: 3–7 days. Full remodels: 3–8 weeks, depending on complexity.
